October 16, 2021 House of Trust

Malaysian School Closures cost RM80 billion a year

THE Centre for Market Education and Bait Al-Amanah published a new policy brief, The Economic Impact of School Closures in Malaysia, authored by Abel Benjamin Lim, Fariq Sazuki, Benedict Weerasena and Dr Carmelo Ferlito.

The paper highlights how the policies implemented by the Malaysian government to attempt to curb the spread of Covid-19 – namely, the closures of educational institutions and, in particular, schools, associated with several lockdowns – have heavily weighed on Malaysian society and life, and proposes policy proposals for a gradual and safe reopening of face-to-face educational activities.

“Recurring to online learning for a prolonged time means being unable to recognize the true essence of education, which is much beyond learning – said Dr Carmelo Ferlito, CEO of the Center for Market Education.

The word education comes from the Latin educationis, the activity of edu-care, which means “to pull out, to extract”. It is thus clear that education does not exist without the virtuous relationship between a pupil and a master, who has the delicate task of pulling out of the pupil his or her best features, helping her or him in the discovery process of their very individual self.

If education was only the transmission of notions, then we would not need schools and teachers at all, we could just supply students with learning materials”. 

“There is a big risk which we cannot yet quantify – declared Abel Benjamin Lim, an economist at Bait Al-Amanah – The risk created by a zero-risk narrative, which has been present since the beginning of the pandemic.

We have a generation growing without proper education and convinced that it is possible to nullify risks in life. Such a generation will not produce entrepreneurs (which are risk-oriented by definition), but only civil servants. This will mean the loss of development opportunities for the country in the next half century”.

The paper’s main findings are:

– School closures seem to be a disproportionately heavy measure in addressing the spread of Covid-19 as the number of Covid deaths among individuals at school age is extremely low (for example, current mortality statistics illustrate that 0.02% of the total Covid-19 deaths in Italy and 0.04% in the United States are of school-age children) and therefore the risk can be minimised with less radical measures.

– According to the relevant scientific literature, school closures have not been proved to be significantly important in containing the spread of the virus.

– The enforced closing of schools generates educational losses in the learning process. In the pessimistic scenario, Malaysia has the highest learning losses across all the Asian developing countries, with an alarming rate of loss of 0.95 years (11.4 months), as shown below:

Source: Asian Development Bank

– School closures are extremely regressive.

– From the economic perspective, school closures could cost, in terms of GDP losses, RM 80 billion per year. In other words, each year of disrupted physical school operations will cost Malaysia the equivalent to 33.3 days (1.11 months) of MCO 1.0-type lockdown or 114.3 days (3.81 months) of MCO 2.0-type lockdown. Under the current scenario, where it seems that the hiccup in education will last three years, the expected total future loss in terms of GDP is RM240 billion. 

– Each year of disrupted physical school operations could bring an expected economic loss per worker of between RM464.26 and RM 1,121.95. For individuals with a degree, such a loss could reach up to RM 2,054.24 per year.

The Centre for Market Education and Bait Al-Amanah proposes the following policy recommendations:

– A discussion for a safe reopening of schools should begin immediately.

– The gold standard for a safe reopening is given by an activity of mass and frequent Covid-19 screening, which means testing each student every Monday. This approach would allow early detection and the isolation of positive cases, preventing asymptomatic contagion and the development of heavy symptoms.

– The program could be financially sustainable thanks to the introduction of rapid testing, the efficacy of which is discussed in the paper.

– The limited cost of a programme based on rapid testing (USD 5/test) could easily be borne by schools and families, while the government should provide subsidies only for real poverty situations.

– Generalised policies should be suspended, where future school closures should be decided on a case-by-case basis and on grounds backed up by scientific evidence. In this regard, engagement with health officials is crucial.

– Education authorities must consider an inclusive approach to reduce the disparities between students once schools begin reopening, addressing the inequality created by lockdowns and school closures. 

– Finally, creative measures should be introduced in order to keep schools open. Among them, creating larger spaces, outdoor schooling, protective bubbles and effective communication

*This article has been published in The Malaysian Insight

*The full policy paper is attached below:

Related Posts

BRT Menjadi Pilihan Iskandar Malaysia

January 29, 2018

January 29, 2018

BRT atau Bas Rapid Transit merupakan pengangkutan awam pertama di Malaysia yang menggunakan teknologi mesra alam. Sistem pengangkutan BRT laluan...

Malaysia must be a voice for peace in Afghanistan

April 5, 2021

April 5, 2021

*Photo Credit: Reuters By Dr Abdul Razak Ahmad (Founding Director of Bait Al Amanah) Earlier last month, the Turkish government...

MEDIA STATEMENT: ACTIVISTS ARE NOT CRIMINALS

August 20, 2021

August 20, 2021

We stand in solidarity with the 31 individuals arrested and compounded during a candlelight vigil held last night for Covid-19...

Countering Violent Extremism in Malaysia

October 26, 2018

October 26, 2018

Summary of “The Role of Universities and Schools in Countering and Preventing Violent Extremism: Malaysian Experience.” written by Ahmad El-Muhammady published...

Parlimen Perlu Undi Pelan Pemulihan Negara dan Pinda Peraturan Mesyuarat untuk Membenarkan Mesyuarat Jawatankuasa Parlimen Secara Maya atau Hibrid

July 28, 2021

July 28, 2021

Kenyataan Komuniti Perintis untuk Parlimen Profesional 27 Julai 2021 1. Kami, selaku kumpulan masyarakat madani yang menandatangani kenyataan ini, mencadangkan...

Terima Kasih Datuk Lee Chong Wei!

June 13, 2019

June 13, 2019

‘Terima kasih Datuk Lee Chong Wei!’ Bait Al-Amanah ingin menzahirkan ucapan setinggi-tinggi penghargaan kepada Olahragawan Malaysia yang telah memenangi 69...

Social Statistics Malaysia 2018

January 10, 2019

January 10, 2019

The Department of Statistics Malaysia recently released the Social Statistics Bulletin Malaysia 2018. This interesting bulletin which is based on...

Teks Penuh Ucapan Bajet Johor 2018

November 28, 2017

November 28, 2017

Post Views: 830

SEED Community: Rombakan Jawatankuasa Pilihan Khas Parlimen Perlu Proses Yang Lebih Telus dan Terbuka

October 11, 2021

October 11, 2021

Kami, selaku kumpulan masyarakat madani yang menandatangani kenyataan ini, maklum bahawa Mesyuarat Pertama, Penggal Keempat Parlimen Keempat Belas bagi Dewan...

Thank You New Zealand !

March 27, 2019

March 27, 2019

A Note of Thanks to the People of New Zealand We are deeply grieved by the horrifying terrorist attack in...

Ke Arah Kemapanan Pasir Gudang

September 19, 2019

September 19, 2019

Selaku penduduk Pasir Gudang, saya sentiasa terpanggil dan mengikut rapat perkembangan insiden pencemaran berulang di kawasan ini. Isu ini nampaknya...

SEED Community: Memorandum Persefahaman PN-PH: Sebuah Batu Loncatan untuk Reformasi Parlimen dan Politik

September 15, 2021

September 15, 2021

Kami, selaku kumpulan masyarakat madani yang menandatangani kenyataan ini, menanggapi berita berkenaan Memorandum Persefahaman tentang Transformasi dan Kestabilan Politik (MoU)...

Team Johor – The Spirit of Volunteerism

January 10, 2018

January 10, 2018

Volunteerism has no expiry date.  Doing good has no time limit. It is something we do every time the opportunity...

The New Decade of Johor

February 5, 2018

February 5, 2018

“Progress is Dynamic. No full stops, no finality. It should point towards a greater vision – not just achieving a...

Media Statement: Budget 2020 Roundtable Dialogue

September 18, 2019

September 18, 2019

The Bipartisan Budget 2020 Roundtable Dialogue with the Theme “United We Tack to Avoid Potential Recession” was successfully held on...

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *